Discovering Bedstuy Mike's Pizza: A Brooklyn Institution
Nestled in the vibrant heart of Bedford-Stuyvesant, Brooklyn, Bedstuy Mike's Pizza stands as more than just a pizzeria; it is a cornerstone of the local culinary landscape. Located at the accessible address of 905 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11206, United States, this establishment has carved out a significant niche for itself by consistently delivering quality, tradition, and a genuine taste of New York City's famed pizza culture. For residents and visitors alike seeking an authentic slice that speaks volumes about neighborhood heritage, Mike's offers an experience rooted deeply in community spirit and culinary dedication.
The aroma of baking dough, simmering tomato sauce, and melting cheese that drifts out onto Myrtle Avenue is an invitation hard to resist. In a city saturated with pizza options, Bedstuy Mike's has managed to maintain a distinct identity. This success is not accidental but the result of meticulous attention to detail, sourcing quality ingredients, and honoring time-tested preparation methods. Whether you are grabbing a quick lunch between errands or settling in for a relaxed dinner, the atmosphere here is welcoming, reflecting the diverse and energetic character of the surrounding neighborhood.
Understanding what makes a local favorite endure requires looking beyond the menu board. It involves appreciating the commitment to consistency and the role the establishment plays in the daily rhythm of life in Bed-Stuy. Bedstuy Mike's Pizza embodies this commitment, serving as a reliable gathering spot where conversations flow as freely as the soda refills, and every pizza promises a satisfying, classic New York experience.
Key Highlights of the Bedstuy Mike's Experience
What sets Bedstuy Mike's Pizza apart in the competitive Brooklyn food scene? Several core elements contribute to its enduring appeal and reputation among pizza aficionados:
Authentic New York Style: The foundation of their offering is the classic New York slice—thin, foldable, yet sturdy enough to hold its toppings. This adherence to traditional style ensures that every order delivers the expected textural and flavor profile that defines great NYC pizza.
Community Focus and Location: Situated prominently on Myrtle Avenue, the restaurant is perfectly positioned to serve the diverse needs of the Bed-Stuy community. Its location makes it a convenient and recognizable landmark, fostering a strong sense of local ownership and patronage.
Commitment to Freshness: While specific details about sourcing are proprietary, the quality of the final product strongly suggests a dedication to using fresh components, from the vibrant tomato base to the perfectly balanced blend of cheeses. This focus elevates their standard offerings.
Versatility in Offerings: Beyond the quintessential cheese slice, the menu often features a range of specialty pies and complementary items, catering to various dietary preferences and cravings while maintaining the high standard associated with the main attraction.
These highlights are the pillars upon which Bedstuy Mike's Pizza has built its lasting legacy. They represent a dedication not just to food preparation, but to providing a reliable, high-quality neighborhood service that respects tradition while remaining relevant to contemporary tastes.
The Enduring Appeal of a Neighborhood Staple
In the fast-paced environment of Brooklyn, where new trends emerge daily, the longevity of an establishment like Bedstuy Mike's Pizza speaks volumes about its intrinsic value. It serves as a delicious anchor, offering familiarity and comfort through its consistent product. For those exploring the rich cultural tapestry of Brooklyn, a stop at 905 Myrtle Ave is highly recommended, not just for the pizza itself, but for the opportunity to partake in a genuine piece of local history.
The experience here is straightforward: excellent pizza made with care, served in an environment that feels instantly familiar. Bedstuy Mike's Pizza understands that the best recipes are often the simplest, executed flawlessly. Whether you are a long-time resident or visiting the area for the first time, this pizzeria offers a warm welcome and a slice that truly captures the essence of Brooklyn flavor.
We invite you to experience the tradition, the flavor, and the community spirit that defines this beloved local spot. Discover why Bedstuy Mike's remains a celebrated name on the Brooklyn pizza map.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Service options
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeaway
Dine-in
Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Offerings
Comfort food
Happy-hour food
Late-night food
Quick bite
Small plates
Vegetarian options
Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Seating
Table service
Amenities
Toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Trendy
Crowd
Family friendly
Groups
LGBTQ+ friendly
Tourists
Transgender safe space
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
Debit cards
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
Menus
Hot Heros
GyroUS$12.00
Chicken ParmUS$15.00
Sausage & Peppers Parm HeroUS$15.00
Meatball ParmUS$15.00
Philly CheesesteakUS$15.00
Chicken Philly CheesesteakUS$15.00
Sausage ParmUS$15.00
Drinks
Lemon SnappleUS$6.25
Peach SnappleUS$4.00
Stewart's SodaUS$4.00
Can Of SodaUS$3.25
Calzones
Sausage, Pepper, & Onion CalzoneUS$15.00
Cheese CalzoneUS$10.00
Chicken CalzoneUS$15.00
Meatball CalzoneUS$15.00
BroccoliUS$6.00
Pepperoni CalzoneUS$15.00
MeatballsUS$6.00
Chicken SideUS$8.00
SausageUS$7.00
Coco Bread SideUS$2.25
Broccoli CalzoneUS$15.00
Fresh Pizza
Grandma SliceUS$5.00
Large Cheese PieUS$25.00
Grandma PieUS$25.00
Hawaiian PieUS$28.00
Meat Lovers PieUS$30.00
Buffalo PieUS$28.00
Regular SliceUS$5.00
Sicilian SliceUS$5.00
Pie With PepperoniUS$25.00
Veggie PieUS$27.00
Margherita PieUS$25.00
Chicken, Tomato & Onions PieUS$28.00
Mini PieUS$13.00
Chicken & Broccoli PieUS$28.00
Medium Cheese PieUS$23.00
White PieUS$25.00
Sicilian PieUS$25.00
BBQ Chicken PieUS$28.00
Appetizers
French FriesUS$6.00
Chicken RollUS$12.00
Pepperoni PinwheelUS$5.00
Buffalo Wings With FriesUS$17.00
Bacon Cheeseburger DeluxeUS$15.00
Cheese Bites (4)US$4.00
Cheeseburger DeluxeUS$14.00
Pepperoni Bites (5)US$5.00
Mozzarella SticksUS$9.00
Cheese French FriesUS$7.00
Beef PattyUS$5.00
Sausage & Peppers RollsUS$12.00
Garlic Knots (4)US$4.00
KnishUS$5.00
Hot Pasta Dishes
Baked Ziti (Ricotta Cheese)US$15.00
Penne Alla VodkaUS$15.00
LasagnaUS$17.00
Ziti Or SpaghettiUS$15.00
Photos
Reviews Bedstuy Mikes Pizza
Jose Rodriguez
09-09-2025
Great pizza spot lots of variety too choose from
Service
Take out
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 4
Ash
26-08-2025
I would go here again. Too much grease from the cheese ( it soaked thru my paper plate onto the table) other than that everything was good.
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 4
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Wait time
10-30 min
Christopher Z
13-08-2025
It's not bad... the regular slice here is better than their slices with toppings IMO.
Service…
More
Patrick Williams
25-07-2025
There pizza abd food options are delicious. It's a neighborhood gem. The staff is warm and attentive. More
Nairb Narud
20-07-2025
Hands-down best pizza in the neighborhood. And always courteous service. The tip is easily well deserved. Thanks guys.
Daniel Huano
12-07-2025
At the first glance it is nothing special, looks like every other pizza place in NYC. But once you take the first bite you know it is different, it is better. I do not know their secret but it is way better then all the other I have tasted … More
Trevor Levasseur
09-06-2025
Pizza a bit on the doughy side. Wasn't my favorite, idk if I would go again. But was good in a pinch More
Jose Rodriguez
07-06-2025
Great pizza spot lots of variety too choose from
Service
Take out…
More
Christopher Z
13-04-2025
It's not bad... the regular slice here is better than their slices with toppings IMO.
Service
Dine in
Food: 4
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 2
Recommended dishes
Regular Slice
Chris Kerns
06-04-2025
Yeah... the real deal. Stumbled on this place and WOW! Had the cheese and possibly best I've had. Went to Roberta's the night before and will seek Mike's slice every time. These guys are NY pizza!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Ava Quado
31-03-2025
There's absolutely no tomato sauce in this Hawaiian pizza. I didn't ask for "no tomato sauce", and upon checking the description, it says it's meant to have it. 😒 … More
Kay Patrick
04-03-2025
They always work to get it right! Very friendly and fast service.
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Kay Patrick
25-02-2025
They always work to get it right! Very friendly and fast service.
Price per person…
More
Reviews Bedstuy Mikes Pizza